Crito enters the cell,
depressed himself at the prospect of Socrates' unjust death. Socrates asserts
that a man of his age is lucky to have lived so long, and that his mandated
death has not cut short his life. Next, Crito grudgingly tells Socrates that the
ship from Delos is approaching, marking the end of an annual Athenian
celebration that prohibits political executions for the several weeks of its
duration.
Socrates seems resigned to his
fated death, but Crito attempts to persuade him to allow his friends to help him
escape prison and flee Athens. If this doesn't happen, Crito says, others will
criticize Socrates' disciples for not rescuing their leader from this unfair
sentence. Yet Socrates asserts that following popular opinion instead of the
gods' will is not right. Soon Crito becomes more desperate, hoping to encourage
Socrates with his elaborate and carefully designed plan for escape. He further
suggests to Socrates that unless he agrees to escape, he will be letting his
sons, who still need to be properly educated by their father, down.
Socrates responds by inviting
Crito into a classic Socratic dialogue, in which Socrates asks a series of
questions in efforts to eventually prove Crito's logic faulty. He begins by
convincing Crito that the advice of one "expert" individual, namely
God, should be heeded much more than the advice of countless ignorant people,
namely Athens' as a whole. In this way, he proves to Crito that popular opinion
is irrelevant.
Next, Socrates makes the point
that it is always better to do right than wrong, no matter what the
circumstances. It then follows that although the jurors who condemned Socrates
have wronged him, it would still be wrong to violate the laws by escaping.
Socrates continues by stating that he doesn't believe in doing wrong to others
as a means of retaliation. Crito, helpless in Socrates' logic, quickly agrees
with all of this.
|